Racine alleged that Amazon illegally used the price agreement to exclude competition and sought to force it to end this behavior through litigation; he also demanded compensation from Amazon and was fined.
The litigation requested the court to order Amazon to take various remedial measures, if necessary, so that it can no longer harm competition, which may include so-called structural remedies, which usually refer to termination of the contract.
This lawsuit was filed in the District of Columbia Superior Court, accusing Amazon of using contract terms to illegally maintain its monopoly and preventing third-party sellers on the Amazon platform from selling products at lower prices on other platforms.
The Washington, D.C. Attorney's Office issued a statement stating that such contracts "(created) an artificially high reserve price in the entire online retail market." The statement pointed out that these contracts led to reduced competition, innovation and choice, and ultimately harmed the interests of consumers and third-party sellers.
According to Amazon's requirements, third-party sellers who want to conduct business on the company's platform must abide by its business solution agreement.
Before 2019, this agreement contained a so-called “equivalence clause” that prohibited sellers from offering products on competitors’ online platforms at prices lower than those on Amazon’s platform. However, as the antitrust review has become increasingly tight, Amazon quietly cancelled this clause in March 2019.
The indictment stated that even after deleting the above clauses, Amazon still added an almost identical clause in the third-party seller agreement called "Fair Pricing Policy", allowing Amazon to be able to compete on competing online platforms. Sellers who offer products at lower prices impose "sanctions."
Racine said in an interview on Tuesday that, in response to pressure from Congress, Amazon has adopted a so-called "baiting" operation on its pricing terms.
An Amazon spokesperson issued a statement on Tuesday, saying: “The statement of the Washington Attorney (contrary to the facts) is completely contrary to the fact that sellers set their own prices for the products offered in our store.
Amazon is the best We are proud to offer a wide range of products at low prices, and, like any store, we reserve the right not to offer discounts to customers who are not priced competitively.
The remedies sought by the Washington, DC Attorney will force Amazon to provide more to customers. High prices, which run counter to the core goal of the antitrust law."
Last fall, the House Judiciary SubCommittee of the U.S. House of Representatives issued a 400-page antitrust report that also mentioned Amazon's pricing agreement. The lawmakers agreed that Amazon used its dominant position in the e-commerce field as a bargaining chip to blackmail third-party sellers and required it to comply with the "most favored nation" clause.
Racine said that the lawsuit he initiated targeted such "most-favored-nation" clauses because he believed that these clauses were "a clear policy that would cause third-party sellers to raise prices." He also said: "We know that these terms are unpopular in law, especially when a company like Amazon has a monopoly. We know that Amazon has been criticized for such terms."
A few months before he initiated this lawsuit, US federal and state attorneys have filed antitrust lawsuits against Google and Facebook. Both lawsuits involve many states, but the lawsuit against Amazon on Tuesday came only from Racine's office.
Racine said on Tuesday that he believes that only his own office can solve Amazon's "Most Favored Nation" treatment issue. It is common for states in the United States to cooperate in antitrust litigation or to cooperate with federal law enforcement agencies, especially for litigation involving resource-rich companies, because filing such litigation involves a lot of work.. But Racine said that the issue of "Most Favored Nation" treatment was "loose enough" so that his office could handle it alone.
Nevertheless, he did not rule out the possibility of other states or federal law enforcement agencies intervening, and said that once a state filed a lawsuit, it is common for other states to join or file their own lawsuits. However, he said he is not clear whether other state or federal law enforcement agencies have such plans.
Amazon's third-party market platform is composed of millions of merchants. It currently accounts for more than half of the company's total sales and has become an important part of Amazon's e-commerce business.


Be Civil, No Spam!!!